Tuesday, December 22, 2009
Did Winnie go on her own free will?
On Monday Winnie testified that she had gone with the Tuck's on her own free will. When the defense asked Winnie if she had gone on with the Tuck's she had said yes, then the prosecution stated that had she not gone on her own free will, Winnie could have yelled for help when she saw the stranger. Does this theory prove that Winnie went on her own with the Tuck's? Support your answer with facts and information from the trial.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I think that Winnie did not go on her own free will because she saw the stranger and she could have called out for help but didn't. Gradma Foster said that Winnie was quiet at home and she behaved. I think that Winnie, was scared and she didn't scream out for help.
ReplyDeleteWinnie did not go on her free will because Winnie during the trial said that she felt like she was being kidnapped I say that she was gone against her will
ReplyDeleteI think Winnie did go on her free will because when she saw the stranger she could've screamed out for help but she didn't. Even though Grandma Foster said she was a quiet girl and she behaved, Winnie said that she ranaway from her home cause they were over protective and didn't give her enough freedom.She also said that when she saw the stranger that she could've scream for help but she choose not to.
ReplyDeleteWinnie did go on her own free will because she had a chance to scream and she didn't. PLUS just because her grandmother says that she is shy and quiet doesn't mean that Winnie really is. The only person who would know if Winnie is truly who her grandmother says she is, is Winnie herself.
ReplyDeleteYes Winnie Did Go On Her Own Free Will Because She Wanted To Run Away
ReplyDeleteI think Winnie went on her own free will.Winnie said that she went to the woods and saw Jesse and she was kidnapped.Winnie went on her own free will because when she was on the hourse she had a chance to scream for help but she didnt.
ReplyDeleteI think Winnie didn't went on her free will because in the book it said she was about to drink water from the spring and the Tucks just grabbed her and took her away. Before in the book they have never met so they were strangers to her so who would go with strangers. Winnie was saying she went on her own will because now they were friends that's why.
ReplyDeleteI think that winnie choose to go with the tucks or she went on her free will because when they were passing teh stranger on the horse winnie did not scream for help. she did not scream for help because she did not like her family and did not want to go back sos that proves that she went on her free will. I disagree with juror 5 because in the mocktrial she said she was shy in some cases but not in all cases.
ReplyDeleteWinnie went on her own will. She stated that in the trial that she went on her own will. She went with the tucks when she could've yell for help so it proves she went on her own will.
ReplyDeleteI think Winnie went with the Tucks on her own will, because even though her grandma said that Winnie is a quiet and behaved girl, she still could scream for help when the Tucks stop ans saw the stranger, but she didnt. Also Winnie want to run away, because her parent is too over protective and they dont give her freedom.
ReplyDeleteYes Winnie did go on her own free will because Winnie herself said that she could of yelled for help when she saw the stranger but she did not. Also Winnie could of gone home back to her own family but she did not. Even Winnie herself said that she went on her own will. We have Winnie Foster's testimony to prove that she went on her own free will.
ReplyDeletei agree with juror 5 because her grandmother said that she is very shy and quite when she is at home.
ReplyDeletei think that she did not go own
ReplyDeleteher on free will because she stated that she got kiddnapped
Winnie all ready running away so she did go on her free will
ReplyDeleteWinnie went on her free will because she had no freedom. She saw the stanger but she didn;t call help. That is why she went one her own will.
ReplyDeleteI think that she didn't went on her own will because, even though the Tucks were nice people and explained why they kinapped her, that's still is kidnapping. So Winnie Foster was kidnapped. I'm sorry to say, but there was proof that proves that Winnie Foster were kidnapped by the Mae Tucks. So the prosecution was right she didn't go in her own wil and should have called for help from the stranger.
ReplyDeletewinnie went on her free will cause in her house she had no freedom so that why she ranaway
ReplyDeleteNo because when Winnie answer is that she was being carry alway which means kidnapping. Also i agree with juror 5. Winne is a shy girl at home and to be screaming help it has to be very hard for a girl to behaved in a way she is not use to. And Winne did ran away but by doing so she got kidnapped.
ReplyDeleteI AGREE WITH JUROR 5 AND 15
ReplyDeleteI think it does prove winnie went on her free will because even if she was scared she would have and should have yelled for help.But she didnt.
ReplyDelete